Compare commits

...

1 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Xavier Roche
3e600cff67 htsglobal: int-back hts_boolean (and add hts_tristate) for C++ source-compat
hts_boolean was a real enum {HTS_FALSE=0, HTS_TRUE=1}. C++ forbids assigning a
plain int to an enum, so every C++ consumer of the public API broke on
`opt->field = 1` or `f(opt, 0)`. The exported surface that trips this is wide:
33 hts_boolean fields in struct httrackp, plus two exported parameters
(unescape_http_unharm's no_high, get_httptype_sized's flag). httraqt, the one
reverse-dependency, fails to build against the installed headers, which blocks
the libhttrack.so.2 -> .so.3 binNMU.

Make hts_boolean an int-backed typedef (HTS_FALSE/HTS_TRUE become macros),
fixing the whole exported boolean surface at once: an int is assignable from an
int in C and C++. It is safe here -- hts_boolean has a single definition,
nothing uses the `enum hts_boolean` form, and HTS_FALSE/HTS_TRUE are only ever
0/1 values. ABI is unchanged: an int-sized enum and an int have identical size
and alignment, so sizeof(struct httrackp) stays 141648 and the soname is
untouched.

Five of those fields are not booleans but tri-state {-1 unspecified, 0 off,
1 on}: the -1 is copy_htsopt()'s "leave the target's value" sentinel for merging
a partial options struct onto a fully-initialised one. The old unsigned enum
could not hold -1, so the copy_htsopt `> -1` guard was always true and the field
was always overwritten. Give them a named hts_tristate (int-backed, HTS_DEFAULT
= -1) so the sentinel works and reads honestly, and drop the now-pointless
`(int)` casts. Extend the -#9 copy_htsopt self-test to assert an HTS_DEFAULT
source is skipped.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: Xavier Roche <roche@httrack.com>
2026-06-21 17:46:04 +02:00
4 changed files with 34 additions and 14 deletions

View File

@@ -3703,9 +3703,9 @@ HTSEXT_API int copy_htsopt(const httrackp * from, httrackp * to) {
if (from->maxsoc > 0)
to->maxsoc = from->maxsoc;
/* hts_boolean/enum fields are unsigned (GCC), so a bare `> -1` unset-guard
is always false; cast to int to keep the -1 "unset" sentinel test. */
if ((int) from->nearlink > -1)
/* hts_tristate fields use HTS_DEFAULT (-1) for "unspecified": copy_htsopt
skips them so the target keeps its value. */
if (from->nearlink > -1)
to->nearlink = from->nearlink;
if (from->timeout > -1)
@@ -3732,10 +3732,10 @@ HTSEXT_API int copy_htsopt(const httrackp * from, httrackp * to) {
if (from->hostcontrol > -1)
to->hostcontrol = from->hostcontrol;
if ((int) from->errpage > -1)
if (from->errpage > -1)
to->errpage = from->errpage;
if ((int) from->parseall > -1)
if (from->parseall > -1)
to->parseall = from->parseall;
// test all: bit 8 de travel

View File

@@ -3166,6 +3166,16 @@ static int hts_main_internal(int argc, char **argv, httrackp * opt) {
if (to->parseall != HTS_FALSE)
err = 1;
/* HTS_DEFAULT (-1) is "unspecified": copy_htsopt must skip it,
leaving the target intact. Only a signed (int-backed) field
can hold -1, so this also guards the type against regressing
to an unsigned hts_boolean. */
from->parseall = HTS_DEFAULT;
to->parseall = HTS_TRUE;
copy_htsopt(from, to);
if (to->parseall != HTS_TRUE)
err = 1;
hts_free_opt(from);
hts_free_opt(to);
printf("copy-htsopt: %s\n", err ? "FAIL" : "OK");

View File

@@ -247,13 +247,23 @@ Please visit our Website: http://www.httrack.com
#define HTS_NOPARAM "(none)"
#define HTS_NOPARAM2 "\"(none)\""
/* Boolean flag for option fields and API yes/no returns. An enum (not C bool)
so it stays int-sized: option fields keep the httrackp layout/ABI, and a
return type stays compatible with the int it replaces. */
/* Boolean flag for option fields and API yes/no returns. Int-backed, not an
enum: an enum makes C++ reject `field = 1` / `f(0)` on the exported fields
and params. Int-sized, so the httrackp layout and the ABI are unchanged. */
#ifndef HTS_DEF_DEFSTRUCT_hts_boolean
#define HTS_DEF_DEFSTRUCT_hts_boolean
typedef enum hts_boolean { HTS_FALSE = 0, HTS_TRUE = 1 } hts_boolean;
typedef int hts_boolean;
#define HTS_FALSE 0
#define HTS_TRUE 1
#endif
#ifndef HTS_DEF_DEFSTRUCT_hts_tristate
#define HTS_DEF_DEFSTRUCT_hts_tristate
/* Tri-state hts_boolean: HTS_DEFAULT (-1) = "unspecified" (copy_htsopt leaves
the target untouched); HTS_FALSE/HTS_TRUE = off/on. */
typedef int hts_tristate;
#define HTS_DEFAULT (-1)
#endif
/* Larger/smaller of two values. Macros: arguments are evaluated twice. */

View File

@@ -428,11 +428,11 @@ struct httrackp {
LLint maxfile_html; /**< max bytes per HTML file */
int maxsoc; /**< max simultaneous sockets (-cN) */
LLint fragment; /**< split site after this many bytes */
hts_boolean
hts_tristate
nearlink; /**< also fetch images/data adjacent to a page but off-site */
hts_boolean makeindex; /**< build a top-level index.html */
hts_boolean kindex; /**< build a keyword index */
hts_boolean delete_old; /**< delete locally obsolete files after update */
hts_tristate delete_old; /**< delete locally obsolete files after update */
int timeout; /**< connection timeout in seconds */
int rateout; /**< minimum transfer rate (bytes/s) before abort */
int maxtime; /**< max total mirror duration in seconds */
@@ -465,13 +465,13 @@ struct httrackp {
hts_boolean maketrack; /**< maintain an operations-statistics log */
int parsejava; /**< Java/JS parsing mode; see htsparsejava_flags */
int hostcontrol; /**< ban slow/timing-out hosts; see hts_hostcontrol bits */
hts_boolean errpage; /**< generate an error page on 404 and similar */
hts_tristate errpage; /**< generate an error page on 404 and similar */
hts_boolean
check_type; /**< probe unknown-type links (cgi/asp/dir) and follow moves
*/
hts_boolean all_in_cache; /**< keep all retrieved data in the cache */
hts_robots robots; /**< robots.txt handling level */
hts_boolean external; /**< render external links as error pages */
hts_tristate external; /**< render external links as error pages */
hts_boolean passprivacy; /**< strip passwords from external links */
hts_boolean includequery; /**< include the query string in saved names */
hts_boolean mirror_first_page; /**< only mirror the links of the first page */
@@ -485,7 +485,7 @@ struct httrackp {
hts_boolean sizehack; /**< treat same-size response as "updated" */
hts_boolean urlhack; // force "url normalization" to avoid loops
hts_boolean tolerant; /**< accept an incorrect Content-Length */
hts_boolean
hts_tristate
parseall; /**< parse aggressively, including unknown tags with links */
hts_boolean parsedebug; /**< parser debug mode */
hts_boolean norecatch; /**< do not re-fetch files the user deleted locally */